The PRAXIS Nexus The PRAXIS Nexus

The Road to Better Oxygen Therapy

Posted on September 23, 2024   |   

This post was written by Michael W. Hess, MPH, RRT, RPFT


When I was joining the COPD Foundation in 2020, my boss offered me a mission. It was a bit different role than the one I had applied for, but it seemed like an interesting challenge.

"How would you like to help fix supplemental oxygen?"

Now, I've never been a durable medical equipment (DME) person. I was coming from a position in primary care where I WORKED with a lot of DMEs, facilitating prescriptions and coordinating care. I had a vague understanding of how much the industry had struggled over the last decade, with payment cuts related to the Medicare competitive bidding process. I knew many people had been having a harder and harder time accessing equipment that fit their lifestyle and health goals. I knew that a lot of my respiratory therapist colleagues had been forced to move on because of budget cuts and consolidation. I figured getting to the root causes of the issues and developing strategies to overcome them would be an interesting challenge.

I call that time "the good old days," because I was caught completely off guard by the sheer magnitude of that challenge.

It turns out that here in the United States, we've actually been slowly chipping away at our ambulatory oxygen therapy infrastructure for decades. Some types of equipment, like liquid oxygen, have become essentially extinct because they're too expensive to provide. That, in turn, means that while we clinicians keep telling people that one of the keys to improving quality of life with chronic breathing problems is staying active, the system cannot provide them with the means to do so. Frustration abounds on both sides of the stethoscope, not to mention with the suppliers whose hands are tied.

Compounding the issue are multiple knowledge gaps. Our understanding of the appropriate use of oxygen therapy is based on research published in the early 1980s using essentially homogenous patient cohorts from the US and the United Kingdom. In 2018, an American Thoracic Society workshop report found that many clinicians do not have the appropriate knowledge or resources to effectively prescribe oxygen equipment or to monitor the effectiveness of oxygen therapy. With prescribers unable to instruct people and DME suppliers often unable to provide clinicians in the home, training is often unfairly delegated to delivery technicians, and patients are left in the dark.

It's not just the ambulatory care world that faces challenges. The COVID-19 pandemic revealed and exacerbated major issues with oxygen delivery in acute care settings, too. Many hospitals simply could not keep up with surges in oxygen consumption related to the surges in COVID admissions. In some cases, that led to hospitals needing to divert patients elsewhere because their oxygen pipes were depressurizing to the point of freezing. In worse cases, it led to hospitals running out of oxygen altogether. Regardless of the setting, this critical lack of investment in infrastructure and preparedness has cost lives around the world.

But it doesn't have to be this way. The problems are undoubtedly substantial, but they are not insurmountable. That's why we are proud to be the lead organization for World Oxygen Day, an international campaign recognizing the entire oxygen therapy community. We have designated October 2nd (or “O-2”) as an annual event around which stakeholder groups in the world of oxygen can build campaigns for increased awareness, enhanced education, and community support. Last year's inaugural event focused on building networks and identifying partners, capped by the Oxygen Stakeholder Summit. The Summit brought together a pulmonologist, a DME RT, and two oxygen therapy users (one with pulmonary fibrosis and one with COPD) to share their experiences and viewpoints and identify ways to work together to break down barriers.

This year's event broadens the international scope of World Oxygen Day, as we will be promoting new resources from all over the world. We will be reviewing findings from this year's World Health Organization Road to Oxygen Access meeting in Dakar, Senegal and forecasting next year's Lancet Global Health Commission on Medical Oxygen Security report. We'll also be hearing from oxygen therapy users and other stakeholders about how oxygen therapy has impacted their lives so that the public can better understand the lived experience beyond stereotypes and stigmas. Closer to home, we'll be having a major push to contact Members of Congress to whip support for the Supplemental Oxygen Access Reform (SOAR) Act, legislation designed to start reversing the decades of neglect our DME infrastructure has faced. And we'll be promoting existing oxygen tools and resources because people cannot use tools they do not know exist.

We'd love to hear from YOU, too! There are plenty of ways to get involved, from holding a local event marking the day to recording a short video or sharing our social media materials. You can also sign up for our oxygen-specific e-newsletter (not spam, we promise!) for ongoing updates throughout the campaign and beyond. Let us know how you plan to participate in the comments or at oxygen360@copdfoundation.org!

10 Comments



You need to login to comment.
  • The title is misleading: The Road to Better Oxygen Therapy

    There is no discussion of the better road to be taken, but it is a review of what is wrong with the Oxygen Therapy status.

    When I saw the title I expected to see suggestions as to what to do to improve my use of oxygen, rather than a historical discussion followed by "That's why we are proud to be the lead organization for World Oxygen Day, an international campaign"

    IMO such campaigns frequently use oxygen to produce CO, but I hope that I am wrong and that in fact, the day is a productive one.


    Reply
    • The author of this post and the many folks who work at or are just members of the COPD Foundation work everyday to help improve the lives of people with COPD. World Oxygen Day is a productive day because of the people who work to make it one. It is a long hard fight to help folks who need supplemental oxygen to live as good a life as they can. The people here work to help make that a reality.
      Reply
    • Hi HeWhols - Actually, this IS a discussion of the "Road to Better O2 Therapy" - it involves EACH one of us - patients, caregivers, clinicians, working tirelessly to educate the public and especially the decision makers about the needs of those of us who use supplemental oxygen.

      It's not easy, it's taking a long time - many of us have been advocating for years, calling, writing, emailing and meeting in person with our elected officials to help them to understand the limitations of the current Medicare rules regarding supplemental oxygen use.

      If you want to see things change (which may end up improving your own use of oxygen), please join us in our fight to be recognized as citizens who deserve to live the best lives possible and not be confined in many cases to our homes.




      Reply
    • Hi, HeWhoIs! I appreciate you taking the time to comment, although I'm sorry that you didn't enjoy the article.

      It is nearly impossible to write a community article with suggestions to "improve" someone's use of oxygen, because everyone's needs are usually very, very different. Some people need lighter equipment. Some people need more training on the hows and whys of oxygen therapy. Some people need tips on travel, some people oxygen therapy around the home. We did try to do that about a year and a half ago with an article I co-authored with another respiratory therapist with extensive experience in the home care field and an oxygen therapy user. You may find something you're looking for there, and you can find it on our COPD Digest blog at https://www.copdfoundation.org/COPD360social/Community/COPD-Digest/Article/1822/The-Confusing-World-of-Long-Term-Oxygen-Therapy.aspx.

      I say the "COPD Digest blog" because we actually have two blog channels on our site. COPD Digest is aimed mostly at people with COPD (or similar lung problems) and caregivers. This blog, PRAXIS Nexus, is aimed more towards health care professionals. While I personally feel it's important for both "teams" to have a good idea where each is coming from, priorities and educational needs do tend to be different between the groups. That's why I wrote this article more to help HCPs understand the context of why oxygen therapy is so messed up. The on-ramp to the road to making it better is knowing what's wrong in the first place.

      You make another very good point about campaigns like this being all talk and no action. It is EXTREMELY important to me that World Oxygen Day is NOT that. The road will be a very long one, but what I can tell you is in the last 12 months since the first World Oxygen Day, we saw the WHO meeting that I mentioned (one of the first serious examinations of oxygen problems around the world), and we've seen groups like the Global Oxygen Alliance (GO2AL) use World Oxygen Day as a platform to share their progress with the world (https://globaloxygenalliance.org/news/the-global-oxygen-alliance-go%e2%82%82al-marking-one-year-of-milestones-on-world-oxygen-day-2024/). This year, we are looking to highlight additional progress, and promote innovators in this space. For example, a group from Australia has developed a solar-powered device that can concentrate oxygen and fill tanks. It was originally designed for extremely rural (and, frankly, poor) regions of the world...but I suspect there are a LOT of people in Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, and the Carolinas who could benefit from such a device right now. We are committed to using the World Oxygen Day campaign to promote these innovators and really work to make things better for EVERYONE who needs supplemental oxygen, whether for an hour or for a lifetime.

      If you have questions about your own therapy, I'm here to help! Please feel free to join us on our monthly OxyTalk discussion group, on the second Wednesday of every month at 4:00pm Eastern. Register for that here: https://copdf.co/oxy-talk. You can also sign up for our now-monthly oxygen newsletter at https://copdf.co/worldO2Day. We're here to help!
      Reply
  • Hi HeWhols, in order to make this the article that you were wanting to read, join us on October 2 for world oxygen day. Then support the legislation that should bring about better oxygen therapy.
    Reply
  • Yes the title is a bit misleading as I was hoping to lean something. I am 74 years old, live in Thailand, have severe COPD and would expect that there would be some oxygen therapy which would help improve my quality of life. I have spoken to two of the best COPD doctors in two of the best private hospitals who have stated emphatically that the use of oxygen therapy is only required when I actually cannot breath. There is no oxygen therapy that will improve my quality of life. In my opinion it's the medical profession that needs educating properly in this area of treatment, not the insurance companies who dictate what is the appropriate treatment.

    Reply
    • Hi, Gerryb! Thank you for your comment, although I'm sorry you didn't find the article helpful. Please check out my response above to HeWhoIs for some extra background on that, and you may prefer an article we published a year or two ago: https://www.copdfoundation.org/COPD360social/Community/COPD-Digest/Article/1822/The-Confusing-World-of-Long-Term-Oxygen-Therapy.aspx.

      I wholeheartedly agree that medical professionals need additional education about oxygen therapy. There are a lot of miscommunications and knowledge gaps, which certainly affects the people in their care. Oxygen therapy is helpful to people with blood oxygen levels below a certain point, which is not always related to being short of breath. Quality of life can be a tricky think to consider, too; modern oxygen equipment all too often helps people breathe easier while limiting their mobility and activity at the same time.
      Reply
  • Hi Mike, thank you for your response however your view of "quality of life is tricky to consider" is a pretty negative attitude. I have seen people in the UK walking to the local shops walking with an NHS supplied oxygen cylinder and canula on a small trolley and in Thailand a man shopping with his small oxygen cylinder in his shopping cart. There seems to be many portable oxygen concentrators on the market which only weigh a couple of kilos and can be fiitted into a small back pack. How good these are I do not know. We need exercise and until the community stops saying answers to this are tricky we won't get anywhere. As someone who has severe COPD I take the attitude of "it's a bit tricky" to be unacceptable.
    Reply
    • I think that it is vital to view the issue of oxygen therapy through the eyes of someone who uses oxygen 24/7. The use of oxygen most definitely enhances my quality of life. I would have to sit and do pursed lip breathing during the day to keep my oxygen above 88%.

      While the cannula and the long oxygen tubing cause me countless opportunities to curse during the day, my life is enhanced.

      The cylinders that allow me to walk about without the long tubing are heavy and do not last very long. My POC keeps me saturated as long as I do not walk at my usual pace. I have to slow down so as not to overbreathe the machine.

      I can breathe, so according to your experts I do not need oxygen therapy.

      Reply
    • As a counterpoint, I spoke with an oxygen therapy user just yesterday that said that because she was forced to use a cylinder on a trolley (or a cart, as we call them here), she essentially lost the use of her arm while doing things like shopping. Her supplier said that they would not provide the smaller tanks, and portable concentrators are not an appropriate system for everyone because of the way they deliver oxygen. So, she felt like her life was being diminished.

      To be clear, that something is "tricky" does not imply that we shouldn't keep working on the problem. It just means that there is no one-size-fits-all solution, and we have to keep that in mind as we work to make things better and create solutions that can be adapted to work for everyone.
      Reply